HOME | DD

Description
These are 6 different thumbnail sketches for a contest i will be submitting to. Ill be using one of these sketches to make into a digital painting. heres a link to the contest:[link]
The theme of the contest is "Esgaroth" from Tolken's The Hobbit book. I'll be doing this in 2D in photoshop.
I would love some feedback on which thumbnail i should use and why. thanks!

PS-the scan is dark for a reason: i used a blue drawing pencil to rough these out and it wasnt very dark so the scan had to suffer so that you could see what i was tryin to portray.

Description
These are 6 different thumbnail sketches for a contest i will be submitting to. Ill be using one of these sketches to make into a digital painting. heres a link to the contest:[link]
The theme of the contest is "Esgaroth" from Tolken's The Hobbit book. I'll be doing this in 2D in photoshop.
I would love some feedback on which thumbnail i should use and why. thanks!

PS-the scan is dark for a reason: i used a blue drawing pencil to rough these out and it wasnt very dark so the scan had to suffer so that you could see what i was tryin to portray.