HOME | DD

#spikethedragon #mlpfim #mylittleponyfriendshipismagic #twilightsparkle #season5finale #starlightglimmer #season5mylittlepony
Published: 2015-11-28 21:25:09 +0000 UTC; Views: 27012; Favourites: 888; Downloads: 523
Redirect to original
Description
Isn't it great when your crazy villain is probably the worst part of your episode? In a season of ups and downs, this episode ended it on a high note for me. The idea of "What would have happened if X never occurred" has been floated around the fandom for years now, and it was interesting to see a canon vision. It was also interesting to see a full scale Equestrian war. I think Sombra's alternate reality was my favorite, so it sucks that they blew that first, but none of them were bad persay... Except maybe Discord's, but it was so short, whatever. I think Twilight and Spike were fun, the visuals of the time travel and the fighting were great. It was a well timed and well executed episode.ΒAnd now we get to the elephant in the room. Starlight Glimmer. I will start by saying that her insanity, and the way it visually and strategically played out was fantastic. Her plot was so beyond the realm of reason, that you couldn't help but be impressed by it. Also, can we address that she is the only other pony to crack a Starswirl spell, AND she can fly using magic? Fuckin' Zaheer up in this house. No, all of that was great. It was her backstory that didn't really hit home. That whole thing with her friend was a fine instigator, but there were a few dozen levels of psychotic deterioration between "I lost my childhood friend and have a childish reason for it," to "I'm going to build a hamlet where everyone gets their cutie mark taken away," to "Fuck time and space, I'm going to wreck this person's life forever." I know there would have been a LOT to address if they had gone through each beat, but the instigating event, in my opinion, was not strong enough to justify bringing about multiple end-of-the-world scenarios for the sake of some vengeance. Again, that isn't to say that Starlight wasn't a ton of fun to watch.Β
All in all, a great end to a pretty good season. For those of you familiar with how this works, there is one more image left to do. Finals are in full swing here, so it might take time to get to. But I do hope you look forward to it.
MLP:FiM is (c) Hasbro
Related content
Comments: 58
JojoDaggerback In reply to ??? [2015-12-01 00:29:34 +0000 UTC]
I totally agree with you, as a Alicorn I expected Twilight to be more powerfull than as a unicorn (althought not nearly as powerfull as a 1/4 of her power in the Tirek fight, she was a sinthetic alicorn after all) but that doesn't seems the case. My point is Starlight being as powerfull as was showed is consistent with her first appearence, I only saw reasons for that after I waching this video: www.youtube.com/watch?v=7lsge9β¦ , at first I didn't think much of it but after the final episode I can buy that.
Personally I think they made her so powerfull cause Tirek fight must have had a positive feedback from fans and they decided to recreate it. I didn't like it....Β
Honestly I wouldn't be surprised if Celestia has sended Luna to aided Shining and Cadance just like that... She sended the mane six in likely conditions to figure how beat Sombra withΒ only hours of safety(Cadance and Shining were already exausted) and they almost get caught even before reaching the Crystal Empire. This would explain why he was gaining ground over Equestria,Β without Luna Celestia couldn't beat him
π: 0 β©: 1
CommanderEX In reply to JojoDaggerback [2015-12-01 06:02:33 +0000 UTC]
And that's why Starlight going god mod is what annoy me so much. In fight between Twilight and Tirek, it was simple why the fight was so devastating as he absorbed magic from ponies of most of Equestria and Discord. With Starlight there is no explanation why she could rival an alicorn while levitating herself, making wings complitly useless. There is no backstory or solid explanation why she should be so poweful, no alicorn amulet, no backstory of her having a mysterious master, she just self-tought herself into power beyoung imagination, and I am not fan of that.
π: 0 β©: 0
Anon200 [2015-11-28 22:07:13 +0000 UTC]
To me...I honestly think they went too far with building Starlight Glimmer up as a villain. So much that her reason for being evil was the ultimate "Evil is Petty" trope (I literally exclaimed: "That's IT?!"). I mean, if we could consider that to be a legitimate reason for going so demented , then the CMCs should be practically Tirek considering all the crud they had to put up with from Diamond Tiara and Silver Spoon. But the only thing that made it worse to me was how Starlight Glimmer appears to have expanded the dynamic to the "Mane Seven". In terms of character types...it makes sense. She restores the "two unicorn, two pegasi, two earth pony" dynamic and she's actually superior to Twilight Sparkle in magic (something else that was never really explained...). But in terms of character personality it's more than a stretch.
Nice work on the art, though. And fast too!
π: 0 β©: 1
SpikelyWhiplash In reply to Anon200 [2015-11-29 00:36:21 +0000 UTC]
Yeah, I'm with you on all of these points.
Honestly, Crusaders of the Lost Mark would have been a more satisfying season finale. It's strange, because this 2-parter seems to affect all of space-time, so it should be more awesome by default. And yet, something as relatively insignificant as three fillies getting their Cutie Marks practically moved me to tears.
π: 0 β©: 0
<= Prev |