HOME | DD

SarcasticCupcake5Imaginary Friend
#abuse #death #friendship #pain #sad #shortstory
Published: 2015-04-15 03:46:13 +0000 UTC; Views: 3860; Favourites: 100; Downloads: 0
Redirect to original
Description body div#devskin0 hr { }

I sat on the plush rug, waiting patiently for Delilah. Everyday after school she would meet me in the treehouse to talk. She had purposefully picked a place that symbolized childhood. A treehouse forgotten when its own children had grown up. I worried quite a bit about my dear Delilah, she had a darkness following her precise and delicate movements. She tiptoed around the word, but I still knew. There was a reason she was stuck in her rather immature ways. 


Right on time, exactly 3:17, I saw her charcoal hair peek around the make-shift curtain. "Brandon!" I love the way she smiled at me as if we didn't see each other every day. She knew I'd be there, but she still acted surprised every time. 


"Hello Delilah, how was your day?" I smiled encouragingly. She slowly sat crosslegged next to me, her overflowing backpack placed carefully onto my lap. 


"I'm okay. Today was a good day. I'd rather talk about you, Brandon. Can I hear about your day instead?"


This was to be expected. Delilah often turned the attention to me within moments of her arrival. She came from a place where children should be seen not heard. "My teacher still wants to meet the lovely Delilah Thompson I talk about all day. My poem has been taken to the state competition, people are asking to meet my muse." 


The expression on her pale face was impossible to read. "You know they can't..."


"Why not? You have never given me a reason as to why no one can meet you."


"I can't tell you... I-I wouldn't want to hurt you... or ruin our friendship." She bent her head until her chin rested on her pendant. Once again she had avoided giving me a proper answer.


"None of that makes any sense..." I frowned as her shoulders slumped. "I'd rather not fight."


"Then let's not." Her smile didn't reach her large grey eyes. 


"How has your dad been treating you?"


Delilah's voice cracked. "F-Fine." She subconsciously tugged on her sweater sleeves. 


My heart dropped to the floorboards. "Okay, we won't talk about it."


It was hard to tell how long we sat in silence before Delilah stood. "I have to go." She paused to straighten out every crease in her shirt. I didn't reply as Delilah had never given me a proper answer to that either. She stared at me for a while, then shook her head as if I was in denial about something obvious. By the time I looked away from my shoes, she had vanished again.


I sat for a long time watching a spider crawl in and out of a knothole. It wasn't until I tried to move, that I noticed Delilah's backpack still in my lap. I peered inside, hoping to convince myself she didn't need it. Several textbooks and sheets of paper filled the bag. Despite how full it was, everything appeared perfectly neat, not a folded corner to be seen, color coordinated paperclips marking which papers went with each book. I found myself facing a dilemma. 


Should I leave that bag here in hopes of Delilah coming back for it, or should I go try and find her myself?


I realized I desperately wanted to find Delilah's house, so I slung her heavy bag over my shoulder and struggled down the rickety ladder. I stumbled through the remains of the white picket fence that had once bordered the home. It was hard to imagine someone just leaving this beautiful place behind. No wonder Delilah had wanted to take it over for herself.


The backpack strap dug into my shoulder blade as I walked down the sidewalk. The manicured lawns were replaced by junk filled ones nearly devoid of grass, as I crossed the county line. I was careful to avoid tripping over places where the end of the concrete stuck out. It looked as if someone had tried to jackhammer it all up, then stopped half way through.


Taking into account the homes within the Gregory County School District, I narrowed Delilah's neighborhood down to a mere 27 houses. The sun started to set in the distance as I adjusted the backpack again. 


I wandered the streets for two hours, only able to take three houses off my list in the process. These were the abandoned ones, so I knew Delilah wasn't in one of them. The full moon lit my way as I retraced my steps back to the start of the street. The sounds of angry bulldogs scared me and I took off. The straps felt like hot barbed wire as I ran, panting, away from that awful neighborhood. Eventually I found myself back on my street, so I reluctantly took her bag back to the treehouse.


I could barely manage to get the bag up the ladder before I collapsed. 


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~


The next afternoon I sat on the faded carpet in our treehouse once more. A familiar oval face appeared in the doorway. "Brandon!" Never straying from her script, she gave me a wide smile.


"Did you get in trouble with your dad for leaving your bag with me?" I held the backpack up by its straps. If there was going to be an awful encounter to hear about, we had better get it over with.


Delilah blinked. "Um, no... There weren't any problems with him or my teachers." She sat down, poised as always, in her usual spot.


"Really?" I blinked back.


"Uh... yes. I was just as surprised as you are." She took her bag out of my hands, and placed it in my lap. I dropped the issue and we talked for a while about my day. "I have to go." She leaned over and ruffled my hair, brushing it into my eyes. By the time I had pushed it back, she was gone.


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~


Our routine continued for about a week until Delilah arrived one day teary eyed. Her movements were stiff, as if she was in pain. "Brandon." Her smile was less than half hearted. 


"Are you all right Delilah?" She sat her bag in my lap, before sitting on the spot next to me.


"It's just my dad again..." She rubbed her pendant as she spoke.


"There's nothing just about your dad." I held her cold, soft hand in mine. My throat seized up, I couldn't bring myself to ask the dreaded question. "Did he...?"


Delilah swallowed. She didn't answer for a full three minutes. "They..."


"Fucking bastards." 


"Brandon..." 


"They raped you Delilah! There's no way you can be okay with that."


"You think I don't know what they did? Laying back in their recliners afterwards while I...!" She took several deep breaths. "Never mind..."


"Why do you act as if your problems are irrelevant to me and the rest of the world? I'm just trying to help you..." 


"Because they are... you wouldn't understand." Without letting go of my hand she shifted to pull her knees to her chin. "I never asked for your help."


"All you ever say is that I wouldn't understand, but I'm your friend... I'm here to help you." I squeezed her hand gently. 


Delilah tensed as if she wanted to stand and storm out. I knew she wouldn't do anything out of the ordinary like that. It was too unpredictable for her. "Its best you just come to terms with the fact that no one can meet me, and that there's no way for either of us to interfere with the other's life. If you can't... You'd best just forget about me."


I didn't know what to say, so we sat in silence until she stood right on cue. "I ha..."


"You have to go, I understand." I dropped my head to my chest.


I felt her let go of my hand, and then she was gone.


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~


The next afternoon at exactly 3:17 I heard a soft voice in the doorway. "Brandon."


Delilah sat her bag in my lap then sat down. "How was your day?"


"Fine." I fiddled with the tattered backpack straps. "Yours? And I want the honest answer." 


"...Today was okay..." She stared out the treehouse's window, studying the leaves to avoid looking at me. 


"So last night was the problem?" I sat there waiting for her to tell me the truth. I knew what he did to her. I'd seen the bruises on her thighs during a heatwave earlier that summer. I also knew how often he did it. She was too weak to fight back, and she would't let me help. 


Delilah had accused me before of wanting to play the knight in shining armor. She said I made up problems to solve so I could feel wanted. She turned away from me, just waiting until she could leave. "Just forget about me and my problems, lets talk about you."


"No! He's escalating. Its only going to get worse from here..." I yanked her arm and shoved her sweater sleeve up. Her arms were covered in nasty dark purple bruises, the types of bruises that could only come from the hands of a grown man. "Was he drunk again?" Her demeanor's shift was a good enough answer. "Aren't you even a bit worried about what he does to you?" I poked her stomach. "You're always hungry, you're too tired to eat..."


She didn't even turn around. "I have to go." 


I couldn't do anything but watch her leave.


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~


3:29. I paced around the small treehouse. 3:35 Delilah had never been late. Never. The faster my heart raced the quicker I moved. 3:51. I couldn't stop checking my watch. 4:05. I waited all evening for her, but she never came.


The next day I wandered the streets after she hadn't shown again. "Just forget about me and my problems..." I replayed her words over and over in my head. Had she left me?


I waited, then wandered the next day too. I couldn't sit still. My feet took me to her neighborhood again. I kept hoping she'd look out of one of those houses and see me, but she didn't. The next day, I found her.


It's sad to think that after all Delilah's kindness and compassion, only two people came to her funeral. The grave digger and her only friend. The man didn't see me as I stood next to the casket. I think it was the first time I finally came to terms with the fact that I was just her imaginary friend. 


I was here to protect her from her loneliness, but I couldn't save her from her father. Whether he killed her during another of his vicious attacks, drunk and babbling as he forced himself into his own daughter, or if she took her own life, I guess I'll never know.


But the fact that the bastard wasn't there himself, gave me hope that he'd be in prison for a long time.


Through the wooden lid of the casket, her face was emotionless. Someone had been kind enough to give her long sleeves and pants, so I couldn't see the bruises and scars. Even in death she looked elegant, her pose perfect. She would have appreciated that.


I tried to talk about my made up life of perfection, but in our hearts we both knew I wasn't even real. I often felt real, but if I was, I would have saved her somehow. Delilah wouldn't fight back, and I couldn't. She had always treated herself as if she was the one who didn't truly breathe. And maybe she was right.


I thought it was silly the way she protected my feelings, I had never realized I even had any. I didn't know what to do with myself after Delilah was gone. She was the only one who knew me. 


The only thing I could think to do, was write out Delilah's tale so maybe... maybe she wouldn't be forgotten. I don't know if I'll be stuck here, I'd never considered what would happen to me if Delilah died. I had always hoped she wouldn't need me anymore, and then... I'd just go away.


I still worry about my dear Delilah, and out of habit I still wait for her everyday. She never shows.



Related content
Comments: 97

SarcasticCupcake5 In reply to ??? [2015-06-22 18:24:18 +0000 UTC]

Yeah. ^^

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

Zorbonaut [2015-06-22 17:35:21 +0000 UTC]

This is another one of these stories where the plot twist is right in the title and I still don't see it coming. I tip my hat to you!

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

SarcasticCupcake5 In reply to Zorbonaut [2015-06-22 17:38:15 +0000 UTC]

Thank you so much!

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

Steve-C2 [2015-06-22 16:24:17 +0000 UTC]

Congratulations having this featured as a Daily Deviation!  I'm quite happy for you!

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

SarcasticCupcake5 In reply to Steve-C2 [2015-06-22 16:30:11 +0000 UTC]

Thank you so much for suggesting it!

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

Steve-C2 In reply to SarcasticCupcake5 [2015-06-22 16:32:21 +0000 UTC]

You're quite welcome.  It definitely deserved it.

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

SarcasticCupcake5 In reply to Steve-C2 [2015-06-22 16:42:23 +0000 UTC]

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

gyappumusoka [2015-06-22 15:52:01 +0000 UTC]

1- I did get that vibe. At first I thought Brandon had some kind of psychological trauma, and needed an imaginary friend to help him through that. I banished the thought quickly though.
2- 16-17 years old. 
3-It was definitely a major poignant pillar of sadness. As if what she went through wasn't enough, up until her last moments, her only friend was a fragment of her imagination....or was he?
4- It made sense to me. I believe in a theory that states: Anything we can imagine is real. It exists. It may be in another world, in another dimension, in another reality/existence, but it does. So her constant and powerful imagination has called upon Brandon from another realm.  They both might not have realized it but he was real.
5-The fact that an "imaginary" friend, born entirely out of a girl's mind, is narrating the story even after her death is a unique and original take on this type of writing. I really liked it as it challenged my mind.
6- I believe there is no need for more details on the horrific life she's lead. The precise yet concise descriptions you've used leave room for interpretations that are have far more impact. 

Overall amazing unique story that narrates a sad reality, that exists in frighteningly high numbers in all societies. And the most depressing and sorrowful part about this is that most of the victims, suffer and die in silence. But I suppose there's always hope no matter what.

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

SarcasticCupcake5 In reply to gyappumusoka [2015-06-22 16:49:53 +0000 UTC]

Thank you for the feedback and I'm so glad you liked it.

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

dragoeniex [2015-06-22 13:49:29 +0000 UTC]

I hesitate to call this a "nice" story, given the subject matter, but it read very well. There's a lot of little details I appreciate.

From the start, I was wondering if Brandon was the imaginary friend. His poem contest and mention of friends confused that. Still, Delilah was the one who felt like she'd need a friend most, and she was definitely interacting with someone else off-screen. Brandon is the one who stays in one place, and we don't see him talk to anyone else.

It didn't detract from the story for me, and I sort of liked how he stayed after she died. Makes him a bit more real.

They read like they were around 10 to me. Brandon might be a little bit older, to fit his role as her safe place, and he uses terms like "escalating" she probably wouldn't know.

I'd say you've got enough detail on Delilah's home life as is- especially if you want to keep a twisty sort of end. I don't know how original the idea of having Brandon be the friend was, since I haven't read a lot of the similar stories, but it was a good read.

The fact that no one came to her funeral raises my eyebrows. It seems like a teacher or neighbor would wander in out of obligation, if nothing else. Might even feel bad after learning about the situation.

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

SarcasticCupcake5 In reply to dragoeniex [2015-06-22 16:14:02 +0000 UTC]

Thank you so much for the feedback!

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

ThatAnnoyingRabbit [2015-06-22 13:25:15 +0000 UTC]

 Congratulations on the well deserved DD! I'm so happy for you!!
Keep up the awesome work~   
               

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

SarcasticCupcake5 In reply to ThatAnnoyingRabbit [2015-06-22 15:59:34 +0000 UTC]

Thank you so much!

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

ThatAnnoyingRabbit In reply to SarcasticCupcake5 [2015-06-22 21:56:29 +0000 UTC]

Sure thing! 

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

Rhyn-Art [2015-06-22 12:42:02 +0000 UTC]

Congratulations on your DD

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

SarcasticCupcake5 In reply to Rhyn-Art [2015-06-22 15:59:57 +0000 UTC]

Thank you!

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

Rhyn-Art In reply to SarcasticCupcake5 [2015-06-22 21:16:56 +0000 UTC]

Welcome!

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

HistoryShaker [2015-06-22 12:11:12 +0000 UTC]

1) You DID trick me! I though Delilah was the imaginary friend. Then I got confused, I thought it was kinda strange/suspicious an imaginary friend would have such a dark past and a real father. After a while I decided to ignore the title!
2) At first I thought they were elementary schoolers, then I thought high schoolers, but at the funeral I imagined her as a little girl. I guess she's a little girl in at least a teenage body.
3) The fact that she doesn't have any real friends doesn't make me sad, but it definately wasn't a pointless detail. It doesn't make me sad because she didn't let that fact that she was friendless bring her down. She made her own perfect friend and I think she was satisfied with him. It wasn't pointless since we see what a kind and selfless girl she is. I mean, I don't think she was avoided, maybe unapproachable because she kept to herself. She might've been scared to make friends for various reasons. If she had a friend he/she could have actually helped.
4 )The narrarator not being "real" gave a different perspective on imaginary friends. It showed that an imaginary friend's existance doesn't depend on the creator,at least not until after it's created. Or the imaginary friend still lives on somehow. . . Maybe Delilah lives through him or she's keeping him alive from a better place.
5) Brandon being the imaginary friend does make the story original. The narrator being something we know close to nothing about makes it seem as if imaginary friends do exist. Usually, imaginary friends are side characters, or the SECOND main character, to help the main character.
6) Weeeell, I think everybody always wants to know more about Delilah, her family, and life style. But if you do, it won't really help the story or the message. It's all already clear. You'd just be adding details to a beautiful picture - which I have no objection to.

Aaanyway, now for my comment! ! That last part really got me thinking. What's worse: to be killed by your own flesh and blood or to kill yourself knowing you'll leave behind the only being that mattered to you and you being the only peron that matted to him.
I hope her dad killed her, for justice, and loyalty, hope and endurance.
And also the horrible life Brandon mst be living . . . What's his purpose? Nobody else could see, touch, hear, or feel him. I wonder if he's changed.

Well I'm happy this deviant has a description and doesn't just leave me with a sad moving story like some others. Keep doing your thing; and for some reason for me Brndon still lives on and he's very important in this world, and Deilah I'm pretty sre she's in a much better place. 

I REEAAALLY HOPE TO READ MORE ABOUT BRANDON AND DELILAH. Maybe a prequel with Delilah and a sequal with Brandon. It doesn't matter, I just fell in love with the characters and their relationship and your writing skills. WAY TO GO *THUMBS UP*

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

SarcasticCupcake5 In reply to HistoryShaker [2015-06-22 16:46:45 +0000 UTC]

Thank you so much for all the feedback and I'm delighted you liked it!

I have decided, after your comment and the one I just replied to, the maybe I'll try writing a little more about Brandon and what happens to him after Delilah's death. There is a prequal, its just a few sentences showing the day Delilah dreamed him up. ^^ I never posted it though. 

Thanks again!

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

HistoryShaker In reply to SarcasticCupcake5 [2016-10-10 20:04:58 +0000 UTC]

I just read about the story behind 'Walk Away' by Dia Frampton and I remembered this story
You can find it here if you want: diaframpton.blogspot.com/2011/…

Oh, and I WOULD enjoy the few sentences of prequel, I will absolutely gobble up any thing about this story. It's beautiful, yet so sad! <3 : )

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

SarcasticCupcake5 In reply to HistoryShaker [2016-10-10 20:34:22 +0000 UTC]

Thank you. <3

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

Miera42 [2015-06-22 09:37:24 +0000 UTC]

I agree with the DD (:

In answer to some of the questions;

Personally, I find the story fine as it is. While some things may be added, upon your discretion based off of intent of the story, I don't see anything 'extra' in the story. The main thing is that you feel it brings across the feeling that you meant it to give. There was certainly some 'offness' about it to kind of show how Delilah might have been the 'unreal' one, instead of Brandon, but yet it's still clear who is who in this. (I least I found it clear, but I'm also used to paradoxes and whatnot sort of sideways thinking.) An example would be the treehouse, and Brandon's awareness of Delilah's 'childish' side about visiting it. To me that implies that since Delilah is the one with a clear flaw, she's most likely the one taking refuge from a harsh reality. Which ended up being the case.

I like how Brandon is the narrator for the story, and how he manages to continue on. It makes sense, as well, if you think of the fact that ideas count as nouns. And by this I mean, that once a concept is made, in a way, it never truly 'dies'. It's a noun, a 'thing', even if it's completely intangible. Delilah had put the energy and time into Brandon, to make the idea of him, the concept of him, real. So, even if no one else ever sees him, and as cruel as it may seem for him to still exist without another 'real' person for a friend to give his existence purpose, I like how he'd stick around.

Have you ever thought of having someone else 'see' Brandon? That could be interesting, and could go a few different ways. Would his personality change from person to person, or would his self-identity stay the same? Would Brandon's psyche change, to where he keeps hope person to person even if they die and leave him, or would he become dark and bitter? Would he get 'stronger', the more emotional energy and intent others put into him? Could he maybe become a sort of guardian angel, or a sadistic poltergeist angry and haunting an area?


What would happen if an adult sees him and talks to him? Would the mental state of the people who see him change him, or just how they react to him...or would only those hallucinating be able to see him?

Just some questions that come to mind, if you continued Brandon's story s:

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

SarcasticCupcake5 In reply to Miera42 [2015-06-22 16:39:39 +0000 UTC]

Thank you for all the feedback!

I'd never considered before what would happen to him after. I suppose he could move on to a similar child, changing and adapting alongside them like he did with Delilah. He would stay mostly the same, staying true to the form and personality Delilah gave him. 

I wouldn't have an adult see him simply because it would seem more "psycho" when the innocence of childhood is taken out.

But thank you again, and now I sort of want to continue the story. I think you fixed my writer's block!

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

Miera42 In reply to SarcasticCupcake5 [2015-06-25 16:01:53 +0000 UTC]

I personally think it would be cool if Brandon ended up being like a guardian angel; he's there for children suffering abuse, so that they don't feel alone. That king of thing...a bittersweet kind of painful happiness, if that makes sense? Where it's like there IS a happy ending, but it's still kind of up in the air of whether it happens or not, since it follows a more realistic probability...?

I'm not sure how else to explain it, sorry s: I'll be quiet now ^~^;

But yeah XD

About childhood innocence...if you mean in Brandon, that kind of makes sense. Delilah didn't quite have the 'innocence', anymore, as dark as her life was. I would say that as 'naive' as Brandon could be considered to be, he HAD been aware of and...justifiably...concerned about what was going on. That kind of awareness of something that WRONG, could be considered a lack of innocence. I personally think it'd be interesting if an adult saw him, because they had scars from a past or something that they were still fighting. Kids aren't the only ones who have the imagination and dreams to have an imaginary friend; while it seems weird, even 'off', for an adult to have one, I've know a few grownups who I could easily imagine having a constant companion no one else could see. And it'd seem natural, without them seeming any less intelligent, or any less sane *shrugs*

But that's just me XD

Woot, glad I helped! I guess XD yay random brain was good for SOMETHING, right? s: lol

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

Eremitik In reply to ??? [2015-06-22 09:14:40 +0000 UTC]

Great story, I enjoyed it quite a bit.

As I sat here reading the comments and your questions, letting the impact of your story sink in, I came to the conclusion that Brandon could be the manifestation of Delilahs subconscious. By creating Brandon, her subconscious was hoping that eventually he could convince her to take a stand against her father, to dig deep within herself and find the strength and courage to talk to someone and get the help she needed to stop her father from abusing her.

I found nothing pointless in the story.
Stories dont always have to make sense as real life seldom makes sense. What matters is that your story was well written and it allowed us to suspend belief, believing that Brandon could manifest and write her story even after she was gone.

The lack of details allowed the reader to imagine the abuse. If you had included details, I think it would have cheapened the story some and not had as much impact as it had.

A well deserved DD. Congratulations.

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

SarcasticCupcake5 In reply to Eremitik [2015-06-22 16:15:11 +0000 UTC]

Thank you bunches for the feedback. So glad you liked it!

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

Eremitik In reply to SarcasticCupcake5 [2015-06-24 09:19:15 +0000 UTC]

You are most welcome. The pleasure was all mine.

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

Lintu47 In reply to ??? [2015-06-22 08:32:20 +0000 UTC]

Congrats on the DD!
Have a nice day!

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

SarcasticCupcake5 In reply to Lintu47 [2015-06-22 08:38:52 +0000 UTC]

Thank you!

You too!

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

Lintu47 In reply to SarcasticCupcake5 [2015-06-25 13:59:12 +0000 UTC]

My pleasure, thank you!

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

Noojie-Woojie In reply to ??? [2015-06-22 07:36:23 +0000 UTC]

I never saw that coming! Faved!

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

SarcasticCupcake5 In reply to Noojie-Woojie [2015-06-22 08:31:21 +0000 UTC]

Thank you!

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

GonnaBeey In reply to ??? [2015-04-17 02:17:52 +0000 UTC]

God...this just... ugh. Straight to the heart.
This got me really bad girly. Really bad. 
Congratulations on your insanely good writing skills again

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

SarcasticCupcake5 In reply to GonnaBeey [2015-04-17 02:21:37 +0000 UTC]

Haha, thanks.

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

Stenkuss In reply to ??? [2015-04-15 20:59:44 +0000 UTC]

I really like what you did with the twist ending. I'm a sucker for that sort of thing.

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

SarcasticCupcake5 In reply to Stenkuss [2015-04-15 21:02:39 +0000 UTC]

Thanks, glad you liked it!

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

Stenkuss In reply to SarcasticCupcake5 [2015-04-15 21:04:08 +0000 UTC]

No problem man. 

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

Elslin In reply to ??? [2015-04-15 20:05:19 +0000 UTC]

I like this a lot. I, too, thought it was Delilah who was imaginary. I liked not knowing until the end. I think it is set up perfectly.

On the picky note, just a few spelling errors. Great story!

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

SarcasticCupcake5 In reply to Elslin [2015-04-15 20:10:38 +0000 UTC]

Thank you, glad you liked it. ^^ I'll go back over in search of those pesky spelling errors. 

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

ColdAmuChan In reply to ??? [2015-04-15 05:54:02 +0000 UTC]

I was more so thinking that either Delilah or Brandon had schizophrenia and that their friendship was real yet imaginary. What I found odd was that Delilah never took Brandon home with her. Was she aware that he wasn't real?

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

SarcasticCupcake5 In reply to ColdAmuChan [2015-04-15 05:59:53 +0000 UTC]

I think she subconsciously knew he wasn't real, but she kept him away from her home so he wouldn't get hurt by her father... Delilah couldn't explain why there were restrictions on their friendship, she just knew there were. 

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

ColdAmuChan In reply to SarcasticCupcake5 [2015-04-17 00:02:45 +0000 UTC]

That's some crazy stuff but I liked the story

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

SarcasticCupcake5 In reply to ColdAmuChan [2015-04-17 00:03:41 +0000 UTC]

Thank you.

👍: 0 ⏩: 0

Steve-C2 [2015-04-15 05:42:36 +0000 UTC]

Thoughts ...

Well, I did think that Delilah was the imaginary friend.  How can a figment of the imagination write a poem?  However, when she left her backpack, it threw me a bit.  So I just kept reading, looking for an explanation.

I get the impression that they're in their early teens.

What isn't clear, even to the end, is that Brandon is imaginary.  I can't say the story suffers for it.  But there weren't enough clues for me to deduce that he was a figment of her imagination.  But again, the story doesn't suffer for it.  That she doesn't have a real friend isn't a pointless detail; in fact, it does make the story a bit more poignant.

Heh, the story does make sense, but I do wonder how Brandon would "live" on after Delilah died.

The narrator being the imaginary friend is original.

Truth be told, I think the hints you left are perfectly sufficient for the purposes of the story.  This is a great example of the "Less is more" philosophy.

Just re-read the ending.  You know what's interesting?  Brandon can still be passed off as real.  Not being noticed next to the casket can be attributed to the other person paying such attention to the casket that they're unaware of their surroundings.  And he can consider himself an imaginary friend, in that he only imagined the friendship was there - Delilah looking for an escape wasn't really friends with him, and he might feel as though he wasn't a real friend since he didn't do anything to stop what was happening - thus, "imaginary friend" taking a different meaning than what one would normally expect.

I hope you take it well that I say that, because in my book it leaves more opportunity for thinking.  If Brandon is a figment of Delilah's imagination, then she's suffering horrible abuse and coping.  But if Brandon is real, then we see how things were handled and have to ask, "what is friendship?  What would a real friend have done?"  Looking at it again, this does give plenty of opportunity for the reader to stop and think and consider things happening around them, and really think.

I like how this starts looking like a story about an ordinary kid, then turns to something deeper, darker.  I didn't expect it.

This does give a spooky vibe, and I really shouldn't have read it at 1:30 in the morning before going to bed.

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

SarcasticCupcake5 In reply to Steve-C2 [2015-04-15 06:10:52 +0000 UTC]

Firstly, thank you greatly for the feedback and for answering the questions I left.

I love the "what is friendship" take on the story. It could be used to solve the problem of how he "lived on" so to speak.

I'm not sure how much the backpack threw you off or if that continued to be a problem. The mystery could be left open to a little interpretation. 

Again, thank you, much appreciated! 

👍: 0 ⏩: 1

Steve-C2 In reply to SarcasticCupcake5 [2015-04-15 16:12:09 +0000 UTC]

No problem!

The backpack bit threw me for a little bit, but I put it aside to finish the story, so it wasn't something that kept me from enjoying it.

Also, I had to put on some happy tunes after reading and commenting (shouldn't have read this before going to bed, as I said ...) 

👍: 0 ⏩: 0


<= Prev |