HOME | DD

Description
Here's something a little different: It's a FNAF theory!

The theory is, are there two Foxy's? As in, did the Withered Foxy get scrapped in favor of a new model?

We know that the old withered animatronics would later be refurbished into the ones seen in FNAF 1... except for one.

The new Foxy wasn't. He was built completely from scratch. Here's why:

In FNAF3 there are animatronic parts all over the place. Foxy, for one, has his head up on the wall, and his hook arm is in the box of toy animatronic parts...

...but they don't match.

The head is clearly from the FNAF1 model of Foxy, but the hook arm belongs to the one from the second game. And no, this ISN'T an oversight.
The phantom version of foxy is the same as his FNAF2 model... but with a missing arm. His hook arm, more specifically. And the Foxy heads from FNAF1 and FNAF2 arent' the same at all.

Another thing worth noting is where these were found:

The Phone Dude says on night 1 that they found a Foxy head, presumably in the FNAF1 location. He doesn't mention finding an arm, or the toy animatronics remains.
That means the were found at different times, because they were found at separate locations. And it makes sense, too.

The head of the FNAF1 version of Foxy would obviously be found at it's respective location. The hook from the second version of Foxy was found alongside the box of toy animatronics, both of which at one point were part of functioning animatronics, Withered Foxy and the toy animatronics.

If the other withered animatronics were scrapped as well, their remains would presumably be found in the same spot, right? Well, they aren't. The rest of the group actually got revamped and repaired, but Foxy was flat-out replaced. And I think I know why...

He wasn't woth it. The Phone Guy states how Foxy, or at least, this version of him, was always a bit "twitchy", probably because they might have found him with the dead kids in the Foxy minigame. He's also easily the most damaged, and while the other animatronics were called ugly, Foxy was also called scary. The redesign would be so much work that it would be easier to make a new one from scratch.

Also, the location in FNAF1 wasn't quite as successful as it's predecessor, as it was getting closed down, and at this point everyone knew about the missing children incident, so only a fucking moron would take their kids there. This might explain why Phone Dude accused the Foxy head from FNAF1 as a crappy cosplay: The very few people who went to the FNAF1 location wouldn't recognize this version of Foxy. Also, he was out of order, so even LESS people would know his appearance. The one from the original location, however, would be more recognizeable, since it has been seen in action, entertaining and sometimes traumatizing children. Also, more people went to the orignal location because there weren't any incidents yet.

There's only one flaw to this theory: The FNAF1 Foxy is possesed, even though the child's dead body was stuffed in the FNAF 2 version. To that I have a very simply answer: He went to a new body. When his old, withered Foxy model was dismantled, he simply left and went for the new one. How he did that I don't quite know, but I do know for a fact his soul would leave the old Foxy suit. This can be seen in the FNAF3 minigames, where Purple Guy destroys and thus releases the sould of the dead children.

Welp, that's my theory. Later.

Description
Here's something a little different: It's a FNAF theory!

The theory is, are there two Foxy's? As in, did the Withered Foxy get scrapped in favor of a new model?

We know that the old withered animatronics would later be refurbished into the ones seen in FNAF 1... except for one.

The new Foxy wasn't. He was built completely from scratch. Here's why:

In FNAF3 there are animatronic parts all over the place. Foxy, for one, has his head up on the wall, and his hook arm is in the box of toy animatronic parts...

...but they don't match.

The head is clearly from the FNAF1 model of Foxy, but the hook arm belongs to the one from the second game. And no, this ISN'T an oversight.
The phantom version of foxy is the same as his FNAF2 model... but with a missing arm. His hook arm, more specifically. And the Foxy heads from FNAF1 and FNAF2 arent' the same at all.

Another thing worth noting is where these were found:

The Phone Dude says on night 1 that they found a Foxy head, presumably in the FNAF1 location. He doesn't mention finding an arm, or the toy animatronics remains.
That means the were found at different times, because they were found at separate locations. And it makes sense, too.

The head of the FNAF1 version of Foxy would obviously be found at it's respective location. The hook from the second version of Foxy was found alongside the box of toy animatronics, both of which at one point were part of functioning animatronics, Withered Foxy and the toy animatronics.

If the other withered animatronics were scrapped as well, their remains would presumably be found in the same spot, right? Well, they aren't. The rest of the group actually got revamped and repaired, but Foxy was flat-out replaced. And I think I know why...

He wasn't woth it. The Phone Guy states how Foxy, or at least, this version of him, was always a bit "twitchy", probably because they might have found him with the dead kids in the Foxy minigame. He's also easily the most damaged, and while the other animatronics were called ugly, Foxy was also called scary. The redesign would be so much work that it would be easier to make a new one from scratch.

Also, the location in FNAF1 wasn't quite as successful as it's predecessor, as it was getting closed down, and at this point everyone knew about the missing children incident, so only a fucking moron would take their kids there. This might explain why Phone Dude accused the Foxy head from FNAF1 as a crappy cosplay: The very few people who went to the FNAF1 location wouldn't recognize this version of Foxy. Also, he was out of order, so even LESS people would know his appearance. The one from the original location, however, would be more recognizeable, since it has been seen in action, entertaining and sometimes traumatizing children. Also, more people went to the orignal location because there weren't any incidents yet.

There's only one flaw to this theory: The FNAF1 Foxy is possesed, even though the child's dead body was stuffed in the FNAF 2 version. To that I have a very simply answer: He went to a new body. When his old, withered Foxy model was dismantled, he simply left and went for the new one. How he did that I don't quite know, but I do know for a fact his soul would leave the old Foxy suit. This can be seen in the FNAF3 minigames, where Purple Guy destroys and thus releases the sould of the dead children.

Welp, that's my theory. Later.