HOME | DD

Published: 2013-01-30 12:03:13 +0000 UTC; Views: 17424; Favourites: 120; Downloads: 170
Redirect to original
Description
The break up of the USSR in the late eighties was a messy and often confusing affair. As the SSRs broke away to form new states and federations, the much-reduced Russian Republic held desperately onto a dream of territorial integrity. Independence movements quickly broke out in the Caucasus - long-oppressed Muslims sought national self-determination, and so seized the opportunity.Though their success varied from year to year as the tide of the war flowed back and forth, the Islamic rebels became increasingly radical. Funding and support from extremist regimes in Iran and Turkestan shifted the rebels ever further from the ideals of universal peace. The introduction of NATO troops following several high-profile tourist kidnappings didn't help matters.
Despite the chaos in the Caucasus, Turkic and Islamic minorities further to the east remained surprisingly cordial. Jadidism - a brand of Islam supporting tolerance of other religions - had flourished in the area in the early 20th century. When the USSR's policy on Islam shifted towards intolerance many Jadidist leaders fled to countries where they could be free, not least of all the enlightened and democratic Afghanistan. After the Soviet's fall, these intellectuals and free-thinkers returned to their homelands, once again encouraging their fellows to tolerate other religions and cultures. Unfortunately the Russian government did not share their ideals.
Protests against the Russian treatment of Muslims in the War in the Caucasus went unheeded. Non-violent marches were the subject of police violence. Finally the Turks of the Volga region could stand it no more, and revolt broke out independently in Chuvashia and Tatarstan, with the Tatars later spreading the rebellion to Bashkortostan. After initial clashes it looked like the Russians intended to negotiate a peace, rather than risk another war, but the negotiations were a distraction; a ruse to permit the Russians time to prepare.
Unsuspecting and unprepared, Chuvashia fell within a month. The Tatars and Bashkirs - who had been planning to gain independence together as the United Republic of Tatarstan and Bashkortostan - accepted the fleeing Chuvash militia and government with open arms. The leaders of the three nations spoke at length; they all knew of the abortive attempts at regional independence during the last great chaos of Russian history, and the similarities were undeniable. Despite their differing religions, the Chuvash, the Tatars, and the Bashkirs were able to agree on an equal union of their countries - the Idel-Ural Federation.
The agreement was the easy part; they had yet to win their independence. They fought long and hard - though the Russians were determined to regain the natural resources and industry of the region, the Turkic rebels stalwartly fought back.
Disgusted by the news of human rights abuses coming out of Russia, politically active people from across the world sought to support the freedom fighters in any way they could. They protested. They marched across cities; they chanted slogans; they blocked up streets; they stood off against police; and they called and shouted. Finally, they were heard. The USA and other NATO countries put pressure on Russia to resolve the situation in the Volga region peacefully, lest they withdraw their support in the Caucasus and use trade sanctions to assault Russia's already beleaguered economy. The Russian leadership assured them that they were doing *everything* in their power to resolve the situation, and they'd reached out to the rebels but they're just so *unreasonable* - I mean you know how it is with *Muslims*, am I right? Eh?
The West did not find Russia's response adequate. It was a quiet, almost friendly slap in the face - a dare from their so-called allies. It was Russia's way of saying "You need us too, and don't you forget it". What the Russians failed to realise, however, was that they needed the West more, and that they - not Russia - held all the cards.
A no-fly zone was declared - Turkish, Turkestani, and Afghanistani planes enforced it whilst the US brought its significant air force to bear. Without control of the skies, the Russian advance faltered, and the Idel-Ural armed forces began pushing back.
At long last the Russians got the hint - there was no way they were going to win this, so they might as well cut their loses. A hasty ceasefire was negotiated, with sizable demilitarised zones protecting the Idel-Ural rebels from further Russian depredations. The Glorious 24th of May would go down in history as the day the Chuvash, the Tatars, and the Bashkirs won their independence.
It would be years before the full extent of Russia's human rights abuses in Chuvashia would become known, but if you asked the people of the Idel-Ural Federation if they could go back knowing what they know now, they'd say they wouldn't've done it any other way.
-----
Another map for the Map of the Fortnight contest over on AlternateHistory.com. This fortnight's contest was to make a map of a country that has a government and controls territory, but remains unrecognised. As might be evident from the description, this map takes place in the same world as my previous map of Afghanistan.
Overall I'm quite proud of this, though I'm not sure I'll ever want to present maps as a fake webpage ever again - making that UI was honestly much more frustrating than the map itself!
Edit: Something I forgot earlier; the title comes from the US Declaration of Independence, which I thought was appropriate.
"When in the Course of human events, it becomes necessary for one people to dissolve the political bands which have connected them with another, and to assume among the powers of the earth, the separate and equal station to which the Laws of Nature and of Nature's God entitle them, a decent respect to the opinions of mankind requires that they should declare the causes which impel them to the separation."
Related content
Comments: 68
Kurarun In reply to ??? [2013-01-31 06:40:35 +0000 UTC]
Well the internet became a big thing about a decade earlier - international activism is about as prevalent in this timeline's 2003 as it is in our timeline's 2013.
π: 0 β©: 1
mdc01957 In reply to Kurarun [2013-01-31 08:43:54 +0000 UTC]
And apparently has actually more clout in government compared to OTL.
π: 0 β©: 1
Kurarun In reply to mdc01957 [2013-01-31 11:17:15 +0000 UTC]
Well a number of American allies - such as Afghanistan, Turkey, Poland, and Hungary - were already pretty miffed about NATO getting involved in the Caucasus and took the opportunity to add their voices to that of the protesters. The popular opinion in countries like Britain, France, and Germany was also leaning towards support for the rebels, and the protests pushed them over the edge so it became the majority opinion.
π: 0 β©: 1
varpho In reply to ??? [2013-01-30 13:50:18 +0000 UTC]
very interesting.
what do you mean by "Despite their differing religions, the Chuvash, the Tatars, and the Bashkirs" - do you mean they followed different schools of Islam?
what stance did the Uralic peoples [like Udmurts] take towards this rebellion?
and a nice flag of the Federation - am i right in noticing that you have combined the historical flag of Idel-Ural with a motive known from the new flag of Mari-El Republic? [i'm not able to see it clearly, because the flag is too small].
also, what's the story behind the Tatar flag with a white stripe? i understand the green colour stands for Tatars [just like on the flag of Tatarstan *here*], but is this flag your imagination, or have you found it in some sources?
sorry for many questions, but i'm really interested in this topic.
π: 0 β©: 1
Kurarun In reply to varpho [2013-01-30 16:15:27 +0000 UTC]
No need to apologise - I love it when people get interested in my maps!
I suppose I forgot to explain the "differing religions" part - what I meant was that the Chuvash are Orthodox Christian, whereas the Tatars and Bashkirs are Sunni Muslims.
I doubt the Uralic peoples in the area were exactly pleased with Russia's newfound penchant for oppressing ethnic minorities within its borders, but they didn't rise up in revolt like the Chuvash, Tatars, and Bashkirs did. This is probably due to the lack of an international community for these people to join - there are a number of developed Muslim nations in the world at this point (Afghanistan, Iran, Balochistan, Turkey, etc.) to encourage the Tatars and the Bashkirs, and Pan-Turkism is at its height with one nation (Turkestan) specifically being founded on it, so that includes the Chuvash too. The primarily Christian Uralic peoples wouldn't've had that international support. It's also the case that Russia tried to demonise Muslims in the media, in the hopes of increasing national approval of the war in the Caucasus - the more conservative members of the Uralic communities may have been convinced, and so would've supported solidarity with the Russians until the "Muslim menace" could be put down.
Of course after the Idel-Ural Federation's independence a lot of things are likely to change in Russia - NATO would be unwilling to support their war in the Caucasus as it becomes evident that permitting minorities' self-determination can solve most issues of stability, and it would become evident to the Uralic minorities that the issue is not so much with the Muslims, but Russia's attitude towards them, and that their own independence from such an intolerant regime is entirely possible. I wouldn't be surprised if the Idel-Ural Federation gained a few neighbours, or even a few member states in the decade after its independence!
Very perceptive regarding the flag - it is indeed the flag of the Idel-Ural Republic (blue, with a yellow tamga) with a piece of the Mari-El flag recoloured at the hoist. Originally the white area was just going to be a flat rectangle but I decided I wanted it to have a fancy border, so I nicked the one from the Mari El flag.
The Tatarstan flag is one I designed quickly in order to differentiate it from our timeline - the green stands more for Islam than the Tatars themselves in this version, as the red section standing for Russians isn't there for contrast. The white stripe represents peace, as it does on our world's version, though it's been moved and rotated a bit. Mainly I just thought a green flag with a diagonal white stripe in the left half looked cool. Plus it's quite good for making flags of political movements or organisations, as the triangle the white stripe creates in the upper left acts like a canton - you can change the colour and add a logo or symbol, making it obviously the flag of a movement/organisation, but remaining obviously Tatarstani!
Any more questions? I love answering them. :3
π: 0 β©: 1
varpho In reply to Kurarun [2013-01-30 19:29:59 +0000 UTC]
yeah, Chuvashes are indeed Orthodox, interesting, i've thought they are mainly Muslim. it seems i have to learn more about the peoples of ex-Soviet Union. it's never enough.
i was asking about the Finno-Ugrians because *here* they did take part in the formation of the Idel-Ural state.
as far as this tamga is concerned - it always seemed a little bit strange for me, that it is placed near the fly of the flag, not in the canton, where it would be best visible... i've found some examples of the flag with another orientation of the emblem.
π: 0 β©: 1
Kurarun In reply to varpho [2013-01-31 07:25:00 +0000 UTC]
The Uralic/Finno-Ugrian peoples in the region too part in the Idel-Ural State in this timeline, too - this rebellion is more fuelled by international Turkic and Islamic activism, hence their (initial) exclusion.
I like the Tamga being placed towards the fly - it seems foreign and original, and I really like flags that move outside the norm in simple ways like that. Hence the altered Tatarstan and Bashkortostan flags.
π: 0 β©: 1
varpho In reply to Kurarun [2013-01-31 23:51:42 +0000 UTC]
yes, i also like this feature of the Idel-Ural flag, it is very unique, but... it is kinda impossible because while flying the flag on wind it is the less visible part of the flag. BTW probably that's why Scandinavian flags have off-centered crosses.
i was wondering if the Idel-Ural flag was really like that from the beginning and if it is not a later modification / error.
is there any photo of the Idel-Ural flag with the tamga near the fly?
and there is an interesting hypothesis by AntΓ³nio Martins on FOTW :
"could this image be a spurious reconstruction from a cloth only design showing the upper right hand side instended as the hoist (because of muslim tradition) and not as the fly?β¦"
on Vexillographia.ru there is a flag with the tamga pointing down, not right.
π: 0 β©: 1
Kurarun In reply to varpho [2013-02-01 03:17:16 +0000 UTC]
I can't find any hard evidence either way, but if it's a mistake that could be made in our timeline, then it can be made in this timeline too. Besides, I think it looks cooler this way.
π: 0 β©: 1
varpho In reply to Kurarun [2013-02-01 20:07:47 +0000 UTC]
definitely it looks good, at least in print / on a website.
π: 0 β©: 0
Spiritswriter123 In reply to ??? [2013-01-30 12:44:14 +0000 UTC]
This seams so real, well done
π: 0 β©: 1
Kurarun In reply to Spiritswriter123 [2013-01-30 13:02:26 +0000 UTC]
Thanks! It was hard designing a fake web browser that looks suitably different whilst remaining realistically funtional - I'm glad I managed to pull it off!
π: 0 β©: 1
Spiritswriter123 In reply to Kurarun [2013-01-31 02:41:21 +0000 UTC]
Originally, I thought this was a real thing going on, just never hear of here (Since America is not a supporter)
π: 0 β©: 1
Kurarun In reply to Spiritswriter123 [2013-01-31 06:42:18 +0000 UTC]
Haha! Nah, if something like this really happened you would hear about it - I mean, I'm sure you heard of Russia's invasion of Georgia in support of South Ossetia, and this is a *MUCH* bigger deal than that.
π: 0 β©: 1
Spiritswriter123 In reply to Kurarun [2013-01-31 12:46:50 +0000 UTC]
What is the capital of this country?
π: 0 β©: 1
Kurarun In reply to Spiritswriter123 [2013-01-31 13:34:45 +0000 UTC]
I hadn't thought about that when I made the map, but I'd guess it'd be Kazan - it's relatively central, and it was the capital of the original Idel-Ural State too.
π: 0 β©: 0
<= Prev |